I haven't tried out those products personally, but I have pretty good reason to believe that if your daughter is picky and is used to the DDR experience on Playstation, this may be a really poor alternative. The arrows, graphics and all around gameplay are a poor ripoff of the original. The demo I tried at a mall kiosk had poor reaction to the steps and wasn't very fun to play. Sorry to burst your bubble, but if you end up getting a poor version, I'd hate to see you get stuck with it. Good luck on your search! =)